Top 25 All-Time Best Sundance Movies

By Rick Brough

#25: Four Weddings and a Funeral

For many years, the festival opened with a major premiere, and the films on display were usually underwhelming. (Don’t blame the programmers, since January, post-Oscar deadlines, is a tepid season to unveil new movies.)

The exception to the rule was this 1994 premiere.  With Mike Newell directing, this story of a group of friends at the aforementioned five gatherings became a hit.  Hugh Grant, with his charming stammer and fluttering eyelids, finally got Andie MacDowell, and became a major rom-com star.

#24: Saw

It’s possible that Sundance historians aren’t bragging about this.  But it’s a fact that the Midnight program in 2004 debuted James Wan’s feature about a doctor imprisoned in a bathroom and forced into a horrid “game” by a nihilistic captor named Jigsaw.

The film has generated nine sequels, and it arguably spawned a wave of “torture-porn” movies during the 2000’s.

#23: The Full Monty

The film didn’t exactly rock Sundance when it appeared in the World Cinema program in 1997, but movie audiences later embraced this story, directed by James Cattaneo, about six unemployed men in an English steelworking town forming a male-stripper act.

The “Hot Stuff” scene, with the men boogeying in the unemployment line, became iconic.

#22: Clerks

This 1994 entry in the U.S. Dramatic program focused on Dante, a convenience store clerk, and Randel, his frenemy from the neighboring video store, as they cope with weird customers, a dead body in the bathroom, and the moral nuances of blowing up the Death Star.

Creatively, director Kevin Smith has blown hot and cold in the years since, but you gotta love the guy who brought us Jay (Jason Mewes) and Silent Bob (Smith himself.)

#21: Fruitvale Station

A Sundance award-winner in 2013, this drama about the last hours of Oscar Grant, who died from a police shooting in 2009, introduced the world to director Ryan Coogler and his star Michael B. Jordan.

Both men worked together again on the film “Black Panther” and the “Rocky” spin-off, “Creed.”

#20: Crumb

Sundance documentaries have often explored/exposed our pop-culture icons.  Perhaps none did it better than Terry Swigoff’s 1994 film on R. Crumb, creator of the “Keep On Truckin’” meme and “Fritz the Cat.”

The film shows Crumb’s art, his sexual obsessions, and his siblings (who make Crumb, by comparison, look like the normal one.)

#19: Little Miss Sunshine

A 2006 Premiere,  clicked with audiences despite being loaded with Sundance-movie cliches.  A dysfunctional family (check) including a neurotic gay uncle (check) a troubled teen (check) and a motivational-speaker dad whose life is a mess (check) go on a road trip (check) to enter their little girl in a farcical toddler beauty pageant (check.)

The film was directed by Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris, and Alan Arkin won an Oscar as a foul-mouthed grandpa (check.)

#18: Slacker

Writer-director Richard Linklater was discovered with this  1991 Dramatic entry.  His film gave a name to a generation, as he introduces us to a host of weird philosophical denizens of Austin, Texas.

Linklater later went on to make “Dazed and Confused”, the “Before” romantic trilogy and has an entry in this year’s Episodic program.

#17: Hereditary

Hereditaryshows that Sundance’s Midnight program has given us some modern horror classics.  Ari Aster’s film focuses on a family dealing with horrible tragedy and an occult legacy left by their dead grandmother.

The film not only premiered at Sundance 2018, but was filmed on Utah locations, including the Utah Film Studio near Highway 40.

#16: Citizen Ruth

The film, originally titled “Meet Ruth Stoops”, appeared in the 1996 U.S. Drama program, apparently after someone said, “Hey, who’s up for an abortion-rights comedy?”

Laura Dern plays a pregnant druggie mom, with both right-to-life and pro-choice activists out to exploit her.   Director Alexander Payne has gone on to such films as “Election”, “Sideways” and this year’s “Holdovers.”

#15:  The Whole Shootin’ Match

The seed of Sundance was planted with the Utah/U.S. Film Festival, held in Salt Lake in 1978, which screened mostly Hollywood classics, but also included a small batch of what were called “independent” films.

“The Whole Shootin’ Match” directed by Eagle Pennell, was a comedy/drama about two Texas redneck buddies and their futile schemes to strike it rich.  The film won a major award at the 1978 festival, and Robert Redford later remarked that the film partly inspired him to think about an organization that could help aspiring movie-makers—an idea that became the Sundance Institute in 1981.

#14: CODA

The title stands for “Child of Deaf Adults.”  The film, directed by Sian Heder, deals with the coming-of-age conflicts of a girl who is the only hearing person in her family.

The film was not only a big award-winner at Sundance’s 2021 event, but it became the first Sundance premiere to win a Best Picture Oscar the following year.  It also won honors for Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Supporting Actor (Troy Kotsur.)

#13: The Big Lebowski

The festival has shown films from Joel and Ethan Coen over the years, but usually they weren’t premieres or they weren’t commercial successes.  However, Sundance hit the jackpot in 1998 with the World Premiere of “Lebowski”—an updated, surreal version of an L.A. detective thriller that mixes in a shaggy hero, the Dude (Jeff Bridges), bowling, nihilists, a mystical cowboy and the 1991 Gulf War as backdrop. Somehow, it really ties the room together!

#12: Stranger Than Paradise

How do you describe a funky Sundance movie from 1985?  Let’s say it’s a story about two hangdog hipsters; one is exasperated when his female Hungarian cousin comes visiting, but he gradually falls in love with her, as the story moves from New York to Cleveland, to Florida, to a twist ending.

Jim Jarmusch has been one of those directors who kept making films his way and didn’t wait for someone to knock on the door and offer him a Marvel movie. (The same description could apply to Sundance regulars like John Sayles, Hal Hartley, and more recently, Ira Sachs.)

#11: Poison

It’s hard to highlight one film to illustrate the gay cinema of Sundance in the 90’s.  But one could point to Todd Haynes’ 1991 entry, with three tales told in different styles: a mother’s confession about her criminal son, told in documentary style; a horror-movie parody about a mad scientist; and a lurid prison story.

Other noteworthy films came later in the decade from Gregg Araki (“The Living End”) and Rose Troche (“Go Fish.”)

#10: The Usual Suspects

A crackling-good crime thriller from 1995 directed by Bryan Singer and written by Christopher McQuarrie.  Kevin Spacey, winning his first Oscar, led a superb cast.

Fans are still debating the film’s two major mysteries: one, who is Keyser Soze and two, what the hell is Benicio Del Toro mumbling?

#9: Brother’s Keeper

Four aging illiterate brothers, the Ward boys, lived a ramshackle existence at their New York dairy farm.  But in 1990, Bill Ward was found dead, and the brother with whom he shared a bed, Delbert, was suspected of his murder.

In this documentary from Sundance 1992, filmmakers Joe Berlinger and Bruce Sinofsky brought intimacy and insight to what could have been a tabloid tale.  They showed similar skill with the “Paradise Lost’ case, which became a trilogy of films from 1996 to 2011.

#8: Memento

Guy Pearce plays a man searching for his wife’s killer, although he struggles with short-term memory loss.  On top of that, the movie audience is watching his story in reverse!

Christopher Nolan made his mark with this U.S. Dramatic entry for Sundance 2001.  Since then, he’s become one of Hollywood’s hottest directors, with the Batman trilogy, thoughtful epics like this year’s “Oppenheimer” and the occasional film that still makes us think “WTF?”

#7: The Blair Witch Project

Three student filmmakers ventured into Maryland’s Black Hills in search of the Blair Witch.  They were never seen again, but their footage was found.  That’s just a story, right?

Directors Eduardo Sanchez and Daniel Myrick blurred the lines between fact and fiction for this 1999 entry to Sundance’s Midnight program.  The film went back to the tradition of scaring audiences with what they don’t see and generated a wave of “found-footage” horror flicks. (But were the actors happy with the suggestion that their performances were just real life?)

#6: Capturing the Friedmans

This classic from Sundance 2003 shows that even in a documentary, it’s difficult to see where the truth lies.  The Friedmans, a middle-class Long Island family, are plunged into a storm when the patriarch and youngest son are accused of sexual abuse.

The story is told not just through filmmaker Andrew Jarecki and media coverage, but a cache of home-video footage shot by the family themselves.

#5: Napoleon Dynamite

I like to think this 2004 comedy is about small-town LDS life as seen through a fun-house mirror.  Maybe it’s because co-creators Jared and Jerusha Hess went to BYU, or because the film was shot mostly around Preston, Idaho.  Or because Napoleon is Sundance’s most irresistibly nerdy hero.

In any event—Vote for Pedro!  And get your own tots!

#4: Get Out

At the 2017 Festival, audiences who showed up for a “TBA” screening in the Midnight program experienced one of the most memorable of Sundance premieres.

Jordan Peele directed and wrote a story about a young black man (Daniel Kaluuya), visiting his white fiance’s outwardly-liberal family, who finds himself facing a nightmarish version of “Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner.”  The result was scary and occasionally funny and boasted an insidious horror-movie metaphor about the subjugation of black bodies.

#3: Reservoir Dogs

The quintessential dark, edgy and funny Sundance movie, which premiered in 1992 and unleashed Quentin Tarantino on the world.  This doomed-heist movie is not for the faint of heart, but every member of the ensemble cast is in top form.

The message of the movie is partly that, just like us, gangsters disagree about tipping, and enjoy the Super Sounds of the Seventies.  Mostly, it shows that these “professional” criminals are destroyed by their emotional connections to each other—and also because one of them is bat—t crazy.

#2: Hoop Dreams

If you aren’t a sports fan, who wants to watch a film about high-school basketball that’s nearly three hours long?  But audiences were gripped by this 1994 documentary, because director Steve James didn’t place his emphasis on the hoops, but on the dreams of his protagonists.

The film follows two Chicago-area youths, William Gates and Arthur Agee, and their alternately rising and falling fortunes as they pursue basketball stardom.  It still fits on any short list of great documentaries.

#1: Sex, Lies and Videotape

It’s very rare when you can say one film caused a seachange.  The Sundance Festival was in the doldrums in 1989.  It’s likely no one expected much from a debut film from a guy named Steven Soderbergh.  It concerned a weird drifter (James Spader) who videotapes women’s sexual confessions; a troubled wife (Andie McDowell) her callous husband (Peter Gallagher) and the wife’s precocious sister (Laura San Giacomo.)

There’s a report that Soderbergh was a volunteer driver for the festival, just a year before he won the Audience Award at Sundance.  “Sex, Lies” put Sundance and independent film on the map, and made the Park City festival a hot commodity for the following decade.